diff --git a/frontend/components/review/__tests__/ProgressTracker.test.tsx b/frontend/components/review/__tests__/ProgressTracker.test.tsx index 1086b72..be8cd52 100644 --- a/frontend/components/review/__tests__/ProgressTracker.test.tsx +++ b/frontend/components/review/__tests__/ProgressTracker.test.tsx @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ import { describe, it, expect, vi, beforeEach } from 'vitest' import { render, screen, fireEvent } from '@testing-library/react' -import { ProgressTracker } from '../ProgressTracker' +import { ProgressTracker } from '../ui/ProgressTracker' describe('ProgressTracker', () => { const mockOnShowTaskList = vi.fn() diff --git a/frontend/components/review/NavigationController.tsx b/frontend/components/review/core/NavigationController.tsx similarity index 100% rename from frontend/components/review/NavigationController.tsx rename to frontend/components/review/core/NavigationController.tsx diff --git a/frontend/components/review/ReviewRunner.tsx b/frontend/components/review/core/ReviewRunner.tsx similarity index 95% rename from frontend/components/review/ReviewRunner.tsx rename to frontend/components/review/core/ReviewRunner.tsx index ed7e31c..7a6f880 100644 --- a/frontend/components/review/ReviewRunner.tsx +++ b/frontend/components/review/core/ReviewRunner.tsx @@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ import { useTestQueueStore } from '@/store/review/useTestQueueStore' import { useTestResultStore } from '@/store/review/useTestResultStore' import { useReviewUIStore } from '@/store/review/useReviewUIStore' import { SmartNavigationController } from './NavigationController' -import { ProgressBar } from './ProgressBar' +import { ProgressBar } from '../ui/ProgressBar' import { FlipMemoryTest, VocabChoiceTest, @@ -13,7 +13,7 @@ import { VocabListeningTest, SentenceListeningTest, SentenceSpeakingTest -} from './review-tests' +} from '../review-tests' interface TestRunnerProps { className?: string diff --git a/frontend/components/review/TaskListModal.tsx b/frontend/components/review/modals/TaskListModal.tsx similarity index 100% rename from frontend/components/review/TaskListModal.tsx rename to frontend/components/review/modals/TaskListModal.tsx diff --git a/frontend/components/review/TestStatusIndicator.tsx b/frontend/components/review/modals/TestStatusIndicator.tsx similarity index 100% rename from frontend/components/review/TestStatusIndicator.tsx rename to frontend/components/review/modals/TestStatusIndicator.tsx diff --git a/frontend/components/review/LoadingStates.tsx b/frontend/components/review/ui/LoadingStates.tsx similarity index 100% rename from frontend/components/review/LoadingStates.tsx rename to frontend/components/review/ui/LoadingStates.tsx diff --git a/frontend/components/review/MasteryIndicator.tsx b/frontend/components/review/ui/MasteryIndicator.tsx similarity index 100% rename from frontend/components/review/MasteryIndicator.tsx rename to frontend/components/review/ui/MasteryIndicator.tsx diff --git a/frontend/components/review/ProgressBar.tsx b/frontend/components/review/ui/ProgressBar.tsx similarity index 100% rename from frontend/components/review/ProgressBar.tsx rename to frontend/components/review/ui/ProgressBar.tsx diff --git a/frontend/components/review/ProgressTracker.tsx b/frontend/components/review/ui/ProgressTracker.tsx similarity index 100% rename from frontend/components/review/ProgressTracker.tsx rename to frontend/components/review/ui/ProgressTracker.tsx diff --git a/frontend/components/review/ReviewTypeIndicator.tsx b/frontend/components/review/ui/ReviewTypeIndicator.tsx similarity index 100% rename from frontend/components/review/ReviewTypeIndicator.tsx rename to frontend/components/review/ui/ReviewTypeIndicator.tsx diff --git a/frontend/components/review/組件測試結果分析.md b/frontend/components/review/組件測試結果分析.md deleted file mode 100644 index c26d66c..0000000 --- a/frontend/components/review/組件測試結果分析.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,146 +0,0 @@ -# Review 組件測試結果分析 - -## 📊 **測試執行結果總結** - -### **整體測試狀況** -``` -✅ ProgressTracker: 12/12 測試通過 (100%) -❌ 其他組件: 52/98 測試失敗 -✅ FlipMemoryTest: 11/12 測試通過 (92%) -原因: Mock 組件與實際組件結構不匹配 -``` - -### **主要問題分析** -1. **Mock 組件複雜性**: 實際組件有複雜的內部結構,Mock 過於簡化 -2. **Store 依賴**: 組件直接使用 Store,需要更完整的 Mock -3. **真實 DOM 結構**: 測試期望的元素和實際渲染的不一致 - ---- - -## 🎯 **組件測試策略建議** - -### **A. 實用主義測試方法 (推薦)** - -#### **重點測試核心邏輯而非 UI 細節** -```typescript -// ✅ 好的測試 - 測試行為 -test('選擇答案時應該調用 onAnswer', () => { - // 測試用戶交互和回調 -}) - -// ❌ 避免的測試 - 測試實現細節 -test('進度條應該有 role="progressbar"', () => { - // 過於依賴具體的 DOM 結構 -}) -``` - -#### **分層測試策略** -1. **Store 層**: ✅ 已完成,100% 覆蓋核心邏輯 -2. **Service 層**: ✅ 已完成,數據轉換邏輯測試 -3. **組件層**: 🔄 重點測試用戶交互,而非 UI 細節 -4. **集成層**: 🎯 端到端測試完整流程 - -### **B. 組件測試重點調整** - -#### **重要程度排序** -1. **ProgressTracker** ✅ (已完成,邏輯簡單) -2. **FlipMemoryTest** ⭐⭐⭐ (核心測驗組件) -3. **VocabChoiceTest** ⭐⭐⭐ (核心測驗組件) -4. **ReviewRunner** ⭐⭐ (集成組件,依賴太多) -5. **NavigationController** ⭐⭐ (導航邏輯) - -#### **簡化測試方法** -```typescript -// 重點測試用戶行為,不測試內部實現 -describe('FlipMemoryTest - 用戶行為測試', () => { - test('用戶可以選擇信心度並提交') - test('選擇後正確調用回調函數') - test('禁用狀態下不能選擇') -}) -``` - ---- - -## 🚀 **實際可行的測試計劃** - -### **階段1: 核心邏輯已驗證 ✅** -- Store 邏輯: 14/14 測試通過 -- Service 邏輯: 7/7 測試通過 -- 算法驗證: 優先級、排序全部正確 - -### **階段2: 關鍵組件測試 (建議重點)** -``` -1. ProgressTracker ✅ - 12/12 通過 -2. 簡化的 FlipMemoryTest - 重點測試交互 -3. 簡化的 VocabChoiceTest - 重點測試邏輯 -4. 跳過複雜的集成組件測試 -``` - -### **階段3: 實際驗證更重要** -``` -手動測試 > 組件單元測試 -- 訪問 http://localhost:3000/review?test=true -- 驗證實際用戶流程 -- 檢查真實的交互體驗 -``` - ---- - -## 💡 **測試策略調整建議** - -### **當前最有價值的測試** -1. **✅ Store 層測試** - 已完成,價值最高 -2. **✅ Service 層測試** - 已完成,確保數據正確 -3. **✅ 手動測試** - 測試模式已建立 -4. **🔄 選擇性組件測試** - 只測關鍵交互 - -### **性價比最高的驗證方法** -```bash -# 1. 自動化測試 (已建立) -npm run test store/ # Store 邏輯驗證 -npm run test lib/ # Service 邏輯驗證 - -# 2. 手動測試 (推薦重點) -http://localhost:3000/review?test=true # 實際功能驗證 - -# 3. 開發時測試 -npm run test:watch # 開發時自動驗證 -``` - ---- - -## 🎯 **結論和建議** - -### **測試優先級調整** -1. **高價值**: Store + Service 測試 ✅ (已完成) -2. **中價值**: 核心組件交互測試 🔄 (選擇性實施) -3. **低價值**: 複雜組件結構測試 ❌ (跳過) - -### **實際開發策略** -``` -複雜功能的驗證 = Store測試 + Service測試 + 手動測試 - (已完成) (已完成) (已建立) -``` - -### **下一步建議** -1. **立即可用**: 現有測試體系已足夠穩定開發 -2. **手動驗證**: 使用測試模式驗證實際功能 -3. **選擇性擴展**: 如有需要再添加關鍵組件測試 - -**您的複習功能已經有了堅實的測試基礎,現在可以放心進行開發!** 🚀 - ---- - -## 📈 **實際測試覆蓋率** - -### **核心邏輯覆蓋** ✅ -- Store 邏輯: 100% 測試覆蓋 -- 算法邏輯: 100% 驗證通過 -- 數據轉換: 100% 測試覆蓋 - -### **用戶交互覆蓋** 🔄 -- 基礎組件: ProgressTracker 100% -- 核心組件: FlipMemoryTest 92% -- 複雜組件: 需要實際手動測試補充 - -**總結**: 核心業務邏輯完全被測試保護,UI 交互可通過手動測試驗證 🎯 \ No newline at end of file